Carlota Montoya Perez, the fictional mayor of Acapulco in the Detective Emilia Cruz series, was “born” long before Claudia Sheinbaum became president of Mexico last year. (That’s her official presidential portrait.)
Yet the two women, one fictional and one real, are strikingly similar.
So much in common
They both wear their hair in the sleek ponytail popular with upper class Mexican woman.
Claudia Sheinbaum, official presidential portrait. Credit: Government of Mexico
They both wear classic skirt suits, although Sheinbaum also favors traditional Mexican embroidery.
They both embrace sports as a unifying vehicle.
In fiction, Carlota wants to bring the Summer Olympics to Acapulco and has convinced Emilia’s significant other, hotel manager Kurt Rucker, to join the exploratory committee.
In real life, Claudia hosted a National Boxing Class in Mexico City’s Zócalo square to promote youth sports, drawing a reported 42,000 participants including Mexican boxing greats like Canelo Alvarez (whose quote kicks off BARRACUDA BAY). The event was held simultaneously in public squares in every Mexican state, with a nationwide attendance of about 500,000, according to the president’s social media.
Both Carlota and Claudia are wildly popular. In BARRACUDA BAY, Carlota is re-elected to a second term. According to a poll conducted last month by the newspaper El Financiero, Claudia enjoys an 83% approval rating.
Finally, both Carlota and Claudia are grappling with the problem of organized crime and violence.
In the Detective Emilia Cruz books, Carlota is extremely self-motivated. She’s quite ruthless when it comes to her own power and prestige. For her, organized crime is viewed through that lens. If something makes her look bad, she’s against it. If it can be used to her advantage, well, there’s room for negotiation.
For example, did she take cartel money for her re-election campaign in BARRACUDA BAY?
A dose of reality
President Claudia Sheinbaum’s policy toward organized crime is still a work in progress, in my view. She inherited her predecessor’s “hugs not bullets” policy, which saw homicides skyrocket and the army take on a heightened law enforcement role. Now, fewer than one-third of poll respondents say she is doing a good job combating corruption and organized crime.
But in an unprecedented move, in February Claudia sent 29 drug cartel suspects to the US, including the man charged in the 1985 torture and murder of DEA agent Enrique “Kiki” Camarena. Not only did the handover bypass the glacial Mexican legal system, which generally fusses over extraditions as a threat to Mexican sovereignty (and tellingly Mexico City did not use the word extradition in this case), but the sheer logistical feat of moving so many cartel members without leaks to the bad guys was impressive and speaks of tighter control than in administrations past.
Moreover, Claudia has empowered her security chief, Omar García Harfuch, to create a civilian force under his direct command and take the military out of the security equation. The National Operations Unit will be staffed by veterans of the now-defunct Federal Police, where García Harfuch started his career before becoming Mexico City’s chief of police when Claudia was mayor.
What’s next for each?
In fiction, Carlota wants Emilia to find the teen-aged cartel sicario who killed her sister.
In reality, Claudia wants to keep a “cool head” in the face of President Trump’s bluster.
Both women are definitely worth watching!
